Devotion and Prayer

Spoke of the Wheel of Presence. See also: The Three Paths, Wheel of Harmony.


Devotion is the heart turned toward the Divine as toward someone: a bond with a face and a name, held in love, trust and surrender, and prayer in all its forms is how the bond is lived. Of the three doors through which a human being returns to the ground of being, knowledge, love and action, devotion is the door of love, and for an embodied being the most natural. It differs from the stilled mind of meditation by being a bond between two, and Harmonism’s stance on reality lets it run the whole way: the lover is never asked to dissolve the beloved in order to arrive.

I. What Devotion Is

The Three Paths maps three doors onto the three centres of the human being: knowledge through the brow centre (Ajna), love through the heart (Anahata), action through the will at the solar plexus. The Wheel of Presence gives each door a spoke: Meditation, Devotion and Prayer, Intention. A practitioner may lead with any of them, and a complete practice walks all three.

The twelfth chapter of the Bhagavad Gītā compares the ways and comes down plainly: the way to the unmanifest is harder for embodied beings, because a being with a body is built to love something with a face. That love, directed, is the spoke. It addresses rather than observes; its grammar is the second person, Thou. The Indian cartography names the path bhakti; the Hesychast lineage locates it in the heart (kardia) and prays there; the Sufi stream names its ardour ʿishq; the Pure Land schools of China and Japan built a civilisation of practice on calling the Buddha’s name; the Andean cartography names the love-will munay and treats it as the fabric of the world rather than a feeling about it.

Four neighbours share the spoke’s borders, and each keeps what its own object claims. Meditation holds the way of Love as the stilled mind resting in the heart; this spoke holds the heart’s active bond with its beloved. Sound and Silence holds mantra as a science of vibration; where the chanted name is address to the Divine, a remembrance (dhikr) or the Jesus Prayer, the practice is love carried by sound. Virtue keeps ethical conduct and the vow; this spoke keeps the bond the devotional vow serves. Intention directs the will; asking is a different act. The evening review of the day stays with Reflection.

II. Why Devotion Runs the Whole Way

Every devotional path meets one objection from the non-dual schools. In Śaṅkara’s Advaita, love of the Lord purifies the mind and prepares it for knowledge, and at the end the distinction between devotee and Lord is seen through as appearance. Read that way, the devotee climbs a ladder only to kick it away. Strict dualism fails from the other side: it keeps the two forever apart and never delivers the union it promises.

Rāmānuja answered both in the eleventh century, and his answer is Harmonism’s own stance. In Qualified Non-Dualism the soul is real as a mode of the Divine, distinct inside an unbroken unity: the wave real as wave, the ocean real as ocean. On that ground the devotee is never merely preparing. Love deepens without ending, because the bond it lives in belongs to what is real. The same seeing appears wherever a lineage reaches its summit through love: the Sufi passing away and abiding (fanāʾ and baqāʾ), in which the self passes away in God and abides through Him; the Hesychast deification (theōsis), in which, in Gregory Palamas’s distinction, the soul is united to the divine energies and never absorbed into the divine essence.

III. The Forms of Prayer

Prayer takes seven forms, and a mature practice uses most of them.

Remembrance. The repeated name: the Jesus Prayer of the Philokalia, “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me”; the Sufi remembrance (dhikr); the repetition of the divine name in the Indian traditions (nāma-japa); the recitation of the Buddha’s name (nianfo) that Shandao systematised in seventh-century China. Begun in the mind, remembrance descends, the Hesychast fathers report, to the lips, then into the chest, then into the heart, where the prayer and the one praying fuse.

Praise and worship. Hymn, devotional song (kīrtan), liturgy and the bow of the body: the prostration of the Islamic prayer, the bow before the altar, the salutation that opens a yogic practice. Praise turns attention from the self to what it loves, which is the whole of its work.

Petition. Asking, honestly, for what is needed. Harmonism holds asking as truthful speech to the Divine about one’s condition, never as bargaining.

Intercession. Holding another person’s wholeness before the Divine: the parent praying for a child, a community for its sick.

Offering. Something given with love: the Andean despacho, a bundle of seeds, flowers and sweets offered to the mountains (apus) and the earth (Pachamama) in the reciprocity the tradition calls ayni; the lamp lit before an image; the first portion of a meal set aside.

Surrender. The handing over of the self and its outcome: “thy will be done” in the Lord’s Prayer, the refuge (śaraṇāgati) the Gītā closes on (18.66), the submission that gives islām its name.

The prayer of the heart. Wordless, after the words have done their work: the heart resting in the presence it addressed. Here devotion and meditation touch, and the boundary between them grows thin, as it should.

IV. What Prayer Does

Prayer changes the one who prays, and the evidence sits there. In 2001 Luciano Bernardi and colleagues recorded 23 adults reciting the rosary in Latin and a yoga mantra: both slowed breathing to about six breaths a minute, produced strong, synchronised swings in heart and blood-pressure rhythms, and raised baroreflex sensitivity from 9.5 to 11.5 ms/mmHg (BMJ). Centuries of devotional practice had arrived, by the measure of the line, at the breathing rate the trials of Breathing now favour.

Prayer also trains the senses of the inner life. At Stanford, the anthropologist Tanya Luhrmann randomly assigned Christian volunteers to a month of imaginative prayer, seeing, hearing and conversing with God in the mind’s eye, or to a month of lectures on the gospels; the praying group reported more vivid inner imagery and sharper perceptual attention (When God Talks Back, 2012). The faculty that devotion exercises grows with use.

Whether prayer acts at a distance is another question. The STEP trial, led by Herbert Benson, randomised 1,802 patients awaiting heart bypass surgery: strangers’ prayer made no difference to complications (52.2% among those prayed for without knowing, 50.9% among those not prayed for), and those told they were prayed for fared slightly worse, at 58.6% (American Heart Journal, 2006). That trial tested prayer as a dose delivered by strangers to people they did not know, which is not the bond the lineages describe, and its null result stands as part of the record. Harmonism holds that prayer acts within multidimensional causality, the field the traditions name karma, as every movement of the heart does; that is Harmonism’s reading and the lineages’ claim, and no trial has shown it.

What every lineage reports, and what the one who prays can test, is the change within: attention gathered, fear loosened, the self’s grip on outcomes relaxed, love made habitual.

V. Counterfeits and Dangers

Love carries the strongest current in the Wheel of Presence, and its counterfeits are as strong.

Love transferred to a person. Love owed the Divine fixed on a teacher makes the teacher an idol and the student a dependant, and the history of spiritual abuse runs through that transfer. Harmonism’s model of transmission is the guide whose role ends, never the guru whose role grows (The Guru and the Guide).

Transaction. Prayer as bargaining, a vow traded for a result, turns a bond into commerce and collapses when the result does not come.

Sentiment without change. Feeling in worship and no change in conduct; Virtue keeps the measure.

Compulsion. Prayer repeated from fear that it was said wrongly is the scrupulosity that OCD and the Pathology of Control describes, and it needs care, not more prayer.

Fanaticism. Love of one name turned into hatred of the others. The lineages that went deepest into love are the ones that found the same beloved behind every name.

Bypass. Prayer used to avoid what must be faced (Spiritual Bypass).

VI. The Practice

A time, a place, a name. Morning and evening suit most lives; a corner kept clean and used for nothing else gathers the practice; the name is the one a living lineage gives, or the one that moves the heart. Harmonism privileges no lineage’s name for the Divine, and it holds that a living lineage’s forms carry what improvised ones lack.

A simple session runs in the order of the forms. Begin with praise and gratitude. Turn to remembrance, the name repeated slowly, near six repetitions a minute with the breath, for ten to twenty minutes. Ask for what is needed and hold the people you carry. Rest in silence. End by handing the day over.

Where the mind is agitated or the heart raw, keep to gentle remembrance and shared worship over ecstatic intensity, as the stabilising register of The Way of Presence advises, and let a community hold what a solitary practice cannot.

VII. Devotion in the Way of Presence

In the Way of Presence, Devotion holds the transitional position. Reflection, Virtue, Energy and Life Force, and Sound and Silence clear the moral, ethical, energetic and mental ground; the cleared heart then turns toward what it loves, so that Intention directs a will moved by love, Meditation rests in what the love opened, and Entheogens, where indicated, amplify the cultivation.

The Andean tradition’s word for the substance of it all is munay, love-will: love that moves, and will that loves. A practice that has it lives; a practice without it hardens into technique. This spoke is where it is cultivated directly, and from here it reaches every other.


See Also